Should You Include a Headshot on Your Resume? Pros, Cons, and Best Practices

In today’s competitive job market, candidates are always looking for ways to make their resumes stand out. One of the more controversial methods that people often consider is including a professional headshot on their resume. This approach, however, is not universally accepted and has sparked much debate among job seekers, HR professionals, and recruiters. So, should you include a headshot on your resume? This blog explores the pros, cons, and best practices for making this decision, especially when applying internally within a company.

Why Some Consider Adding a Headshot to Their Resume

Adding a headshot to your resume is more common in some industries and regions than in others. For instance, it’s relatively standard practice in Europe and parts of Asia, but it’s generally discouraged in the United States. However, some candidates believe that including a photo can humanize their application and help them stand out from other applicants. This can be particularly appealing in cases where you’re applying internally within an organization where you’re already somewhat known, as was the case for the original poster in the discussion.

The Thought Process Behind Adding a Headshot

The idea behind including a headshot on a resume is straightforward: visuals can make a lasting impression. If you've been with a company for several years and are applying for an internal position, the thought might be that your photo could trigger a hiring manager’s memory. They might think, "I recognize this person from that project," potentially giving you a slight edge over candidates they haven’t met.

Additionally, in a digital work environment where tools like Slack, Zoom, and Microsoft Teams are widely used, your face might already be familiar to hiring managers. In such cases, a headshot could serve as a quick visual cue to jog their memory and positively influence their perception of your application.

The Risks of Including a Headshot on Your Resume

While the idea of adding a headshot might seem beneficial, especially in internal applications, it comes with significant risks that you should consider carefully.

1. Potential for Bias and Discrimination

One of the primary reasons experts advise against including a headshot on a resume is the risk of bias—conscious or unconscious—during the hiring process. Photos can lead to judgments based on appearance, gender, race, or age, rather than qualifications and experience. This risk is why many companies, particularly in the U.S., have policies against including photos on resumes. They aim to minimize the chances of discrimination claims by making hiring decisions based solely on merit.

2. Automatic Rejection Policies

Some companies have strict policies that automatically reject resumes with photos to avoid any potential bias or legal issues. If you’re applying for an internal position and are unsure of your company’s stance on this, it’s best to err on the side of caution and leave the headshot off your resume. This was echoed by multiple respondents in the original Reddit discussion, who pointed out that some organizations discard applications with photos as a protective measure against bias claims.

3. Perception of Unprofessionalism

In certain industries, especially those in the corporate sector, including a headshot can be perceived as unprofessional or even naive. Recruiters might question your understanding of standard resume practices or view it as an attempt to use your appearance to gain an unfair advantage. This can be particularly damaging if you’re applying for a role that requires a high level of professionalism or judgment.

When Including a Headshot Might Be Appropriate

While the risks generally outweigh the benefits, there are specific scenarios where including a headshot might be acceptable or even beneficial.

1. Creative Industries

In creative fields like graphic design, marketing, or fashion, where personal branding and aesthetics are integral to the job, including a headshot can make sense. Here, the headshot isn’t just about appearance but is part of showcasing your personal brand. If your industry values creativity and visual presentation, a headshot might help you stand out.

2. International Applications

As mentioned earlier, including a headshot is more common in some regions outside the U.S., such as Europe. If you’re applying for a job in a country where this practice is standard, including a headshot may be expected and could even be advantageous.

3. Internal Applications with a Strong Culture Fit

If you’re applying internally within an organization that has a more relaxed or creative culture, and you’re confident that a headshot would be positively received, it could be worth considering. However, it’s essential to know the company’s stance on this practice and weigh the risks before deciding.

Best Practices If You Choose to Include a Headshot

If you’ve weighed the pros and cons and decided that including a headshot is the right choice for your specific situation, here are some best practices to ensure it’s done professionally:

1. Use a Professional Photo

Your headshot should be a high-quality, professional image. Avoid casual photos or selfies, as they can give off an unprofessional vibe. Ideally, your photo should be taken by a professional photographer, with you dressed in business attire appropriate for your industry.

2. Keep It Simple and Discreet

If you choose to include a photo, place it in the upper corner of your resume, perhaps next to your name and contact information. Make sure it’s appropriately sized—large enough to be clear but not so large that it distracts from the content of your resume.

3. Consider the Format

If you're submitting your resume digitally, ensure that the file size remains reasonable even with the photo included. A large file size can be cumbersome for recruiters and might cause issues with applicant tracking systems (ATS).

Alternatives to Including a Headshot

If you’re unsure about including a headshot but still want to leverage your visual identity, consider these alternatives:

1. LinkedIn Profile

Include a link to your LinkedIn profile, where your professional headshot is visible. This allows hiring managers to see your photo if they choose to, without the risks associated with placing it directly on your resume. This was suggested by several participants in the Reddit discussion as a safer alternative.

2. Company Profile or Intranet

If you're applying internally and your photo is already available on the company’s intranet or internal communications tools like Slack or Teams, there’s likely no need to include it on your resume. Hiring managers who are familiar with you can easily recognize your name and associate it with your face through these platforms.

Conclusion: To Headshot or Not to Headshot?

In the majority of cases, especially within the U.S. and for corporate roles, it’s advisable to avoid including a headshot on your resume due to the risks of bias, unprofessional perception, and automatic rejection by some companies. However, there are exceptions, particularly in creative industries, international markets, or specific internal applications where the culture is more relaxed and personal branding is encouraged.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on a careful consideration of your industry, company culture, and the potential risks and benefits. If you choose not to include a headshot, remember that there are alternative ways to make a memorable impression, such as through a well-crafted LinkedIn profile or strategic networking within your organization.

Elevate Your Resume with AI-Powered Tools

Struggling with crafting the perfect resume? Whether you’re unsure about including a headshot or need help highlighting your achievements, resume.live is here to assist. Our AI-driven resume generation service tailors your resume to match your career goals and industry standards. Let us help you stand out from the crowd—visit resume.live today!